New questionnaire aims to improve understanding of demand avoidance in children, teens
Parent reported tool provides structured assessment
For some children and adolescents, demands such as getting ready for school, eating, bathing or going to bed can trigger intense distress.
A team led by University of Michigan researchers has developed a questionnaire to help researchers and clinicians better understand these challenges.
The Demand Avoidance and Autonomy Questionnaire, or DAAQ, is a 36-question, parent reported tool assessing demand avoidance behaviors and potentially associated difficulties with hygiene, eating, sleeping and toileting.
Pathological demand avoidance, or PDA, describes patterns of intense distress and avoidance of demands in response to expectations from others or internal needs or urges. When demands feel unmanageable, some individuals may experience panic, meltdowns, withdrawal or shutdown, or fight-or-flight responses.
Although often discussed in the context of autism, demand avoidance can occur in other conditions and contexts.
Researchers disagree about PDA's definition and whether it represents a distinct condition. The DAAQ does not resolve that debate. Instead, it provides a structured way to assess reported behaviors and daily functioning.
Noelle E. Carlozzi, Ph.D., Professor and Director of U-M’s Center for Clinical Outcomes Development and Application, led the work with Casey Ehrlich, Ph.D., founder and chief executive officer of At Peace Parents, and colleagues at U-M and Northwestern University.
The team developed the questionnaire using established measurement methods, scientific literature, and input from caregivers, adults with lived experience of PDA, treatment providers and measurement experts.
Responses from 707 parents or guardians of children ages four to 17 with suspected PDA supported three separately scored areas: Behavioral Expression, Basic Needs and Toileting.
Initial findings showed promising reliability and validity. The DAAQ was intended for research screening and characterization, not diagnosis.
Scores should be interpreted alongside the child’s circumstances, support needs, and other possible explanations for the reported behaviors. Associations with autism screening measures do not establish that demand avoidance is directly related to autism or that the DAAQ measures autism severity.
Because the study relied on parent and caregiver reports from a self selected sample, further testing in more diverse, independently assessed samples is needed.
“Our goal is to give researchers and clinicians a clearer picture of demand avoidance and the daily challenges families describe, including difficulties with eating, sleeping, hygiene and toileting,” Carlozzi said.
“With further study, we hope the DAAQ will help identify support needs and evaluate whether interventions make a meaningful difference in children’s daily lives.”
Additional authors: Jin-Shei Lai from the Department of Medical School Sciences, Northwestern University, Chicago, IL, USA. Wendy L. Lombard, Christopher M. Graves, Jennifer A. Miner and Madison Fansher from the Department of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. Johnathan P. Troost from the Michigan Institute for Clinical & Health Research, Ann Arbor, MI, USA.
Paper cited: “The Demand Avoidance and Autonomy Questionnaire (DAAQ): Development of a new measure of demand avoidance,” PLOS One. DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0345827